Book Devouring Horde, to the polls!
The first challenge of the intergalactic spouse selection is over.
You now have the chance to make your preference heard and vote for your favorite of the 12 candidates, based on their performance in the debates and your general impression of them!

Name: Ellenda from Team Frowns
Debate Stance: Duty > happiness. Submitting to and successfully carrying out one’s duty ensures the continued survival of society.
Description: an Uma like Kosandion’s mother, tall and graceful, with indigo skin. A select few recognise that she is in mourning, Kosandion amongst them.
Keywords: Defiant.

Name: Pivor of the Murder Birds
Debate stance: Happiness > duty. The purpose of society is to create individual happiness.
Description: handsome stocky man, dark bronze skin and pale silver eyes, dark hair frosted with white. Permanent smile.
Keywords: Handsome and selfish.

Name: Bestata of House Meer
Debate stance: Her purpose in life is devotion to the honour and glory of her House, and the pursuit of personal excellence.
Description: syn armour, platinum blonde hair and equally pale skin. Enough snark to qualify her as an honorary Southern woman.
Keywords: Vampire Knight

Name: Unessa Sybate of the Dushegubs
Debate stance: Me Unessa, you man. Sex make babies.
Description: statuesque, long golden hair, violet eyes, very in-your-face sexual. Left her rebuttal at home, no one told her she had to pack one.
Keywords: Aggressive Dryad, very obvious

Name: Prysen Ol of the Kai
Debate stance: Well, we still don’t know why he’s here…but at least the First Scholar had fun!
Description: lean beautiful male with silky blue hair, golden skin, and pink-colored irises. Everything he does is deliberate and restrained.
Keywords: Dignified wisdom

Name: Nycati of the Gaheas
Debate stance: At most, he was ready to admit that time flows. Possibly. When paired with Prysen, they have a future in the caffeine selling industry.
Description: A secret prince. Lithe, androgynous, long violet hair, can melt a sapient mind.
Keywords: Psionic Elf

Name: Surkar of the otrokar
Debate stance: The best thing in life is crushing your enemies in victory, making them fear and submit.
Description: tall, powerfully built, moves like a predator. Strongest of his clan, he has lost 4 siblings to war.
Keywords: Brash warrior

Name: Oond of the Oomboles
Debate stance: The best thing in life is safety. Make yourself indispensable to others, for apart you struggle but together you prosper.
Description: An ookarish, beautiful being who soothes pain through dance (including that of his opponent). Spectacular orange scales and diaphanous fins, looks painted with fire.
Keywords: Jazz fins.

Name: Cyanide of the Higgra
Debate stance: Que sera, sera. To earn one’s fate, one must prove one is worthy of it.
Description: looks like a mythical snow leopard, golden and white, dainty paws, with blue gums and tongue.
Keywords: Kitty pretty.

Name: Donkamin candidate
Debate stance: We are the architects of our future. Fate is an empty concept.
Description: 8 feet tall, pearlescent skin, vaguely humanoid shape, speaks with an upside down head. Doesn’t have a soul.
Keywords: Creepy

Name: Amphie from Team Smiles
Debate stance: Love is a layered phenomenon that must be examined in a specific context. Its power is immense and its impact is lifelong.
Description: taupe skin, big grey eyes, asymmetric hairstyle. Plays by all the rules of the role she aims for, portraying herself as a Sovereign’s spouse.
Keywords: Practically perfect in every way.

Name: Lady Wexyn of the Temple of Desire
Debate stance: Love is what she feels for Kosandion, he is her favorite.
Description: brunette, curvy and plump, very strong, temptation made flesh, makes it all look easy.
Keywords: Agent of chaos

Should you wish to reread the debates before casting your vote, the relevant snippets are Chapter 14 Part 2 and Chapter 15. The previous vote results can also help, if you’re hedging bets, but it’s early days yet and anyone could get the rose! (I don’t think there’s a rose). Let me know in the comments if you’ve changed your mind since the first poll!
The vote will return after each challenge.
Here we go!
Everyone who thinks Nycati and Prysen need to bromance it out say Aye 😂
Aye
Aye!
Aye!! Or even a marriage/alliance :X
Yes! That! Bromance would be fun, but romance would be too cute for words! Just imagine them trying to define a kiss, let alone something like attraction or desire.
Also, I couldn´t make up my mind the first time, but this time my favourite is Nycati – for Prysen, not Kosandion, but psionic elf and secret prince assassin is just too good.
Aye!
Aye
Aye!
✌️ Aye.
Aye!
Aye
Aye
Or they could form their own romance? (If they so choose) 🙂
Oh yes, it’s a ship ❤
LOL, Aye matey! (So to speak.)
I think Prysen would be the best spouse but I voted for the fish because he’s what we need now 😃
I also voted for the fish!
Totally agree!
Oh, I like Prysen, but I will laugh SO HARD if our Fishy wins.
I voted for the Fish. At first I was going for the Lady Wexyn. And then I thought about the answers, and it seemed the Fish was a clear winner. I thought I’d be in the minority. Guess not.
Aye
Aye, aye!!
As long as one or both is not an assassin, definitely. The Scholar can take his flock to visit them.
Will the scholar teach anyone who is not a Space Chicken? Because they could go study with the Scholar. It would keep those three out of trouble, at least.
OUT of trouble? No way.
Triple aye
Aye
Aye aye! 😉
Eye!
Aye!
Aye. Preferably far away from the rest of us…
😀 pass the java!
Or the Redbull since it gives you wings. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Heh, I have a limited edition one in the fridge and I’m really ready to give in and spike my blood sugar 😀
Aye!
Aye captain!
Aye!!
Aye
Aye!
Aye!
Aye and please make it illustrated!
Aye!
Aye
Aye!
Aye! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Aye
Aye
Aye (obviously ;))
Aye. Maybe they’ll form a nice alliance out of this.
Aye
Aye!
Aye.
Aye
Aye
Aue
Aye
Who thinks they probably already have.
Aye
Aye
Aye! The Schlor would be so happy!
aye
Aye!
Aye
Aye
Aye!
Aye!
Aye!
Aye
Aye aye, cap’n!
Aye
Aye!
Aye
Aye! <3
Aye!
Aye!
Aye!
And see their enemies melt away in confusion …
Aye 😉
Aye!
Aye
Aye!!!
Aye (truly my conclusion reading was “neither of you should go with Kosandion, move in together and never get anything done ever again instead”)
Aye, aye!
Aye
Aye!
Aye! Love it!
Aye!
Aye!
Aye!
What they all said.
But…what IS romance (or bromance)? It might take them the remainder of their lives to define it.
Aye
Yes, immediately. They should leave and help tilt the odds more in the favor of Team Fish.
My first thought when going through the list. Aye!
Aye!
Aye
Aye
Aye!
Aye
Aye!
Oh definitely but it would take FOREVER! LOL.
Aye
Aye!
Aye
Aye!
Belatedly, aye!
Aye yi yi!
Aye
Trying to get to the next actual comment is getting annoying – WAY too many people are infatuated with this idea. It’s not a horrid idea, but I’ve been scrolling for quite a while now…
omg yes! they deserve their own story psionic elf and secret assassin, what could possibly go wrong?!
She! Bromance or romance or whatever but they need to be pen pals at the very least.
AYEEEEEEEEE
Aye 😂
AYE
Aye!
Aye
Aye
Anyone else changing their vote since last time?
Yes, the debate absolutely changed my mind (and Kosandion’s reactions to each).
I’m “Team Fish”. I wasn’t “Team Fish” until I was (no one was more surprised than I).
Likewise. Had Lady Wexyn first time for devious factor, but Oond this time. Especially as Consort to a king. Oond would be great at back-channel negotiations.
same.
I voted Lady Wexyn. This time it’s Oond. I still like Lady Wexyn. But the private conversation with Caldenia… and her Love for Kosandion. I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s telling the truth. But Love can be all consuming. I don’t want Konsandion to have a partner who loves only him. What if she puts her child second to Konsandion? What if her love isn’t returned & she blames there child? So many possibilities.
So after much thought I chose Oond. Learning about his profession. Made me believe that he would be perfect for teaching there child understanding. It doesn’t mean the child will learn empathy but Knowing & understanding your Enemies on a empathetic level. Is a good way to protect there people.🧐😁🧐
Me too! I didn’t know I liked them so much
Yes me too – and I’m kind of gob-smacked to see the results so far. Maybe in real life there’s a heightened awareness among us all of the importance of community and caring for each other – something good to come out of dark times.
Yes, I voted for Cyanade last time, but Ellenda made quite the impression on me this time around. (Oond is of course amazing, but I can’t be too mainstream 😂😂😂)
I think I did the same.
+1
I voted or Oond thinking it would be in the minority. Huge surprise to see it at #1. Very eloquent and well-spoken though.
I too went Cyanide last time, I still like Cyanide, but I think Nycati this time. The psi pic powers are very useful, Nycati is a Royal and has a good idea what that kind of life is like, and he’s here in secret so he knows about sacrifice and political manoeuvring which is really helpful. He’s also obviously intelligent and thinks around things and ideas, not jumping to conclusions. He would be well paired with someone who is more willing to be definitive.
I don’t think Nycati’d make a good companion of Prysen Ol as they would never get anything done, and would get frustrated with each other.
I did like Oond’s debate, and also Pivor’s (the murder birds). I don’t think Cyanide came over well with the bias against those who don’t believe in Souls.
Absolutely changed my vote.
I changed! Never thought I would vote for House Meer, but I clearly grade high for snark. That exchange was just too funny.
I was flat out against House Meer : I didn’t want them to gain any advantage against Arland and Maude and their House — and we all know that the spouse to the leader of an empire will be able to do much for their House — and I wanted House Meer to be deprived of all advantages, at all costs; partly because I want Arland’s House to keep all advantages, and partly to punish Meer for how they treated Dina and the Inn. In fact, I was quite looking forward to Arland crushing them.
However, this Knight rose above all that, and showed herself worthy of respect, and worthy of being a spouse. She has values and work ethic that are worthy of shaping the next generation (to do their duty and carry responsibilities of leadership).
She was good enough that she rose above my starting position that we must crush House Meer, and shut them out from all opportunities.
She made me consider that there might be something worth saving in House Meer.
Perhaps their current experience at the Inn might change their view?
Perhaps the rot that existed previously (and allowed the past bad behaviour) has been purged? One can hope.
p.s. I think Amphie might be an acceptable choice (for duty and honour and carrying the burdens of leadership), also, but I think she is trying too hard, and would be a dreadful bore for him to live with.
While she appears to be a sensible choice, one wonders what is beneath the veneer.
At least with the Knight, there is a frankness that is refreshing. Honesty, duty, and a drive to excel. I really liked hers and Dina’s explanations about the importance of one’s pursuit of excellence. My own views exactly.
Wexyn is a razor blade masquerading as a shallow cow. I echo the comment (made previously) that she has a lot of “favourite” … seems rather convenient.
And Wexyn is not stupid; nobody is that stupid: she is calculating in the extreme.
While one may grudgingly admire the boldness of her strategems (and her entertainment value for the book), she has not shown herself to be able to carry the responsibilities of the roles she seeks.
I agree with Resven: she is utterly inappropriate.
Yay!! Space Fish!
If this were Intergalactic Bake Off instead of Intergalactic Bachelor, I would call him Star Baker (get it, star? space aliens!)
I will see myself out 😅
😂😂😂 thank you for that.
OMG LOLOLOL. <3 this. I can imagine judges Paul and Mary Berry nodding approvingly.
😂😂😂. Best comment ever. But I definitely changed my mind. I don’t know if I *like* Lady Wexyn, but I’m pretty sure she’s deeper than she looks (1st vote – and she’s still who I think will win.). But I voted for Oond because I think he would be a good partner and someone who would care for everyone – even his enemy which could be useful for someone who is going to help rule.
Must have done really well in the showstopper part of the bake off to be star baker. 😉🐟
I enjoyed the debates. Thank you – lots of fun
I voted for the Oond because not only did he debate but tried to make hos opponent feel better by dancing for him!
My winners – in order: Oond, Cyanide, Pivor, Bestada, Amphie.
Prysen & Nycati no winner, both gorgeous but boring zzzzzzz
Team Space Fish!
After the last chapter, I had to vote for the space fish. I loved his debate ♥
Oond’s debate also made me change my candidate. Go Team Space Fish!
Changed my vote to Cyanide because of catch phrase. Who cannot love a pretty kitty?
Lady Wexyn. I still know when there’s a fix in.
You’re a poet and don’t know it.
Oond said “Bless your heart” They have my vote!
While I think ultimately Wexyn’s got this, in the first challenge, Oond had by far the most eloquent and moving performance. United we stand is a great philosophy for a ruler.
Aye and exactly! Good partner plus good ruler is two more important qualities than most 😀 … and if Oond were ever only running away from danger, they definitely wouldn’t be there! But I’m still kind of hoping for Gaston… Also, maybe it’s just me being superficial, but: isn’t it funny that by giving an emotional response to the question regarding love, also an emotion, Lady Wexyn appears to be less intelligent than we know her to be? How weirdly we prize analytical explanations when in the end, they don’t even matter especially in the topic of love…
It’s not the emotion itself, it’s the kiss ass way she said it…
A debate means you give your opponent an opportunity to *debate*. Most readers (and get opponent) agree she did not participate in the challenge which was to debate… Not attempt to kiss ass.
Lady Wexyn pulled a *no* during an improv sketch. She stopped the scene.
Ah ha!! Finally Oond is in the lead!
Cast my vote for Oond with utmost seriousness.
Need to reread before voting!
I like chaos :))
Wooow right now the fish is 1st place. If he marries the fish it wil be soooo funny 😂🤗🤗
I totally changed my vote. I originally voted for Prysen (I think), but after reading the debates, I’m Team Fish. Ellenda and Amphie are tied for 2 (Ellenda has an agenda), and Lady Wexyn is number 3.
+1
And any dark horse candidates?
I think Gaston & Miralitt have promise.
True, but none of them really debated it off. I would guess the Dark Horse in this first challenge is the female otrokar who said “Who cares? We all lost!”
She seemed like a crowd favorite 😀
I also hope First Scholar has his metaphorical bishop’s cap in the accidental marriage ring 😂😂😂
+1
I did not change my vote,although agree that Oond was the best in the debate. I just love Lady Wexyn!
Driving Resven insane! The ovaries of steel to pull the “I’m not even trying” act if she’s actually the assassin!
I don’t even care if she’s the baddie at this point 😀
I think she is the secret Anti-assassin. Team Smiles is the assassin – following the principle „the assassin is always the one who seems least likely to be the assassin“.
PS: who actually voted for the Donkamins????
Yes, I agree, Amphie is way too boring and perfect at the same time to not be the assassin. She just goes under everybody’s radar.
I’m with you 100% on Wexyn being the anti-assassin. Although HA could absolutely make her believably the assassin.
I’m thinking team frowns knows all but is deliberately not getting involved — the gold is mourning Kosandion’s impending death.
And I’d say the least obvious assassin(s) is/are the Oond. Look how moved everyone was by the happy fish dance! They’re even polling at #1 (at the time of this comment).
After them, the Donkamin. I mean, it SEEMS like their job is to just show up and creep the f* out of everyone, and they do it well, but if they have no soul+, how can they become part of the empathic commune that is the Dominion?
+whether or not they are actually soulless, the candidate believes they are.
I really hope Ellenda’s gold paint isn’t mourning Kosandion’s impending death. Dina and Sean should foil any and all assassination attempts.
I don’t even think she is the least likely – she is trying too hard and I would also pick her for the assassin and Lady Wexyn for the “anti-assasin”.
I like Ellenda for the spouse – unless she is mourning not the imminent loss of Kosandionbut the loss of her love by having to participate in this bridal selection.
Lady Wexyn seems to be a liar since her declaration of love doesn’t ring true. Even though Kosandion definitely seemed interested I don’t like her for the bride.
I would love for the space fish to win – but considering the grooms reaction to Lady Wexyns first appearance he is not asexual and I think even IA cannot make an “animal” – human sex scene work…so the “animal” species are right out for me. And for most people intimacy is a big part of being married.
Also, the philosophers need to marry each other and spent their honeymoon with the space chickens.
PHILOSOPHERS IN LOVE??
Yes! Off to review and vote. Thanks for the recap.
Space Fish Oonda for the win! They seem to be the only candidate who are both unafraid to be themselves who and capable of being a positive, helpful mate for a collective kingdom and parent of a future ruler. The others, while fun, are not those I’d trust based on information gathered for a contest – too many hidden agendas. Plus jazz fins and a dance to make his (her/their?) opponent feel better. Bonus points for crowd pleasing appeal.
I still await developments from Lady Wexyn, while eating popcorn. I want her to be in cahoots with Caldenia and Kosandion in pulling off a secret plot of their own. I see her as a cat amongst the pigeons.
If I were to ship Gaston with anyone, it’s be a toss up between Ellenda and Bestata. Another couple I think deserve each other are Pivor and Unessa. Cutest Couple: Cyanide and Amphie.
The “Other” option has been removed, so I’m sticking with my original choice of Lady Wexyn, Agent of Chaos :D. I love that Oond has so many votes though.
The fact that the Costco lady has been tagged to re-appear in the series has me rooting for her though. “Harmony” and “Don’t Mess With Texas!”.
YAS!
I held myself back from bringing up Mrs. Marais / Costco Lady bc I have been so boring about her (mumbling about her at every turn, waiting to see her again) and didn’t want to be THAT person on this blog. So I am soooo happy that there are other MadaMarais-ites! Yay!
Unessa has to stay. I admit I was disappointed in her debate performance, but highly amused. I would like to see if she brings her rebuttal to the date.
Maybe the Dushegubs can grow her one, like moss 😀
Hmmm….tries to imagine what a rebuttal would look like to Unessa 🤣
My brain is just sick and wrong because the image that pops into my head with this comment is twerking Kardashians to the tune of “Baby Got Back”
🎵I like big roots and I cannot lie,
Those other Dushegubs can deny,
When a dryad walks in with an itty bitty brain and a circuitous argument in my face…🎵
I need to be stopped 😛
No, you most certainly do NOT need to be stopped! You go girl!
🤣 Sir Mix-a-lot would be proud!
Hahahahahahaa, I sang that out loud 😀
😂🤣🤣 I wanted to carry on but don’t have your way with words
Oh wow. Perfection.
👍👍
Mod R, you should win ‘Best Response of This Poll Resulting in Much BDH Merriment’ (and yes, I am very sure that is an Official Title) for the rendition of ‘I Like Big Roots’!!
👍👍👍😂
🤣
Please don’t stop!! In fact, I want more!! That was awesome! 😂
Oh, dear. I can’t stop laughing as I hum along to – I like big roots . . .
This could have multiple uses in the Innkeeper world.
The next local nemesis that Dina and Sean face could be a nosy neighbor . . . with stereotypical big, Texas – sized hair. You know . . . big roots . . .
Or, does Gertrude Hunt need a theme song? I’ve got big roots and I cannot lie . . .
Lolzzzzzz
Don’t stop! I love it! 🤣
🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
Pivor. Won his debate. Has hidden depth and might be the assassin. Sneaky murder bird
You would be surprised!
Many thought his “I would hold my survival more important than that of a child” was very much a losing move for a candidate who is vying to be the parent of the Sovereign’s offspring.
Can I refer you to Robert’s argument in KD when talking about Kate’s response to Ascianio being tortured by Hugh. 😂
Different circumstances, different answers.
I still can’t choose anyone. I know, I know – I’m no help at all!
(I love Oond but don’t think he’s a good choice from what I’ve seen so far.)
Still waiting for something – not sure what – but I am sure it will be a great story when it happens…
Team Fish!
I changed my vote from Nycati (even if he might be a prince in hiding) to Oond.
With Nycati you might get psionic powers but fall asleep of boredom before they can be used on you. Oond seemed more society oriented with focus on general prosperity and safety. His compassion won me over.
Me too!
+1 to Team Space Fish. Oond has shown the most compassion of the competitors, and that’s a very attractive trait to me!
I haven’t decided who to vote for, but I am changing my vote when I do. Previously I voted for Prysen, because of the blue hair, but now I don’t know if I trust him, and I think he and Nycati should get paired off, if neither is an assassin.
In the last debate, I liked Oond and Bestata (never thought I would say that about someone from House Meer, plus we don’t want them amassing more power) and Ellenda (but maybe not as the winner).
I am probably in the minority, but I really don’t care for Lady Wexyn. Either she is a good actress (probably) or she is almost as clueless as the dryad. Until she shows her true colors, is she has any, I am marking her as a manipulative schemer or someone too clueless to be the spouse of a sovereign.
Losers of the debate, imo: dryad, murder bird, donkamin
Agree with this…do admit I now really love the fish after this debate…but not as a co-parent with this ruler. Really haven’t picked a over all favorite, just ones I don’t like.
I agree about Lady Wexyn. Don’t like her. She has an agenda and I don’t think it is for Kos’s benefit. Really don’t like her. I really want to see how Clan Nuan’s support for her will figure into this. So far, we have seen no more than Cookie smiling. Hmmmm.
i dont think cooki’s clan is behind lady wexyn, i think that his rival clan is backing her and, that he would like to see lady wexyn falter.
so then cooki’s clan can step in and make some movies.
Clan Nuan, which Cookie is part of, are the second biggest contributors to Lady Wexyn’s Temple of Desire :).
From Chapter 8, Part 2 here https://www.ilona-andrews.com/2022/chapter-8-part-2/
““The Merchants are some of the Temple’s most generous contributors,” he said.
It made sense. The Merchant clans of the Lees, who ran vast financial syndicates, desired things themselves and made their money by catering to the desires of others.
“Clan Nuan?” I asked.
“The second biggest contributor.”
He would know. During his time on Nexus, Sean was part of Nuan Cee’s inner circle. The shrewd little merchant never planned on letting Sean go. He knew the kind of secrets the clan would kill to keep.
“Do you think Lady Wexyn is backed by Clan Nuan?”
“Let’s say I strongly suspect.”
I’m wondering why the secret prince is there but mostly wondering who Kosandion’s Choice is and if he’ll somehow manipulate the outcome. Also does his desired choice know and are they in cohorts?
I still like Pivor, but he most definitely did NOT show well in this challenge. Oond, definitely did the best.
Oond is the kindest being who is part of a collectivist culture. Oond get’s my vote.
I’m still voting for the cat but it wouldn’t break my heart to see Kos with Ellenda, Onnd or Amphie
I was Team Chaos all the way. But her debate turned me off. Not sure of my vote yet maybe team frown because she would save the child. Still love chaos though.
proud to be #teamfish since the first round of voting. 😂😂
The fish is winning!!!
Nycati and Pryson should be a double date with Kosandian. Neither will pay attention to him, Kosandian leaves to do more interesting things, and after 16 uninterrupted hours of discussion/debate, they realize that nobody in the entire dominion is more interesting than each other. I’m afraid, however, that the bromance will not occur to either one of them until they have been together for at least 6 months, because their debate/discussion won’t trend in that direction!
Leaving us with the option the BDH proposed in the first place, they should open a cozy book cafe with interminable book club meetings 😀
Team Fish this time around!
I voted only on the debate. Oond (autocorrect to Pond lol) was the debate winner in my book.
Everything will probably change as we go along – great writing!!!
Does anyone else wonder if Ellende is wearing gold paint to warn Konsandion that someone plans to kill him? Or if she is warning him that she knows he’s killed someone she loves and wants him to understand she will still stand by his side?
Or am I just haring off into the weeds?
Hmmmm.
My theory is that she is the assassin. Her gold paint is an upfront warning to Kosandion, who knows the culture and will understand that. She is acting out of duty (see: her debate statement), and perhaps she doesn’t want to do it.
We shall see!
I wonder if she had to give up someone that she loves in order to do her duty and participate in the marriage selection? … that is what she is mourning, giving up personal happiness for duty. K. is definitely going to try and find out, which is why he bumped her up the list for the one-on-one dates.
Well it’s good to see I’m in the majority !! 🤪
Was just telling my husband about this scene and vote. This blows my mind: not only that House Andrews came up with the idea of a fish character in this setting, but that the character was so well written that it comes up the hands-down winner in a reader poll. I mean, who does this? Your minds are just amazing.
Yes! My man Oond is winning!
While I agree with the portion of the voters that think that marrying a fish would be hilarious, this does not seem feasible. I like the “Love the man” ploy, but is it real. The debaters who cannot come to a conclusion are right out. It will be interesting to see how things develop during the other contests.
I didn’t vote for Oond because they were hilarious, but because of the importance they placed on service to others, to community, which seems like a good fit for the king of a people that have an empathetic bond.
So, Moderator R, does BDH get to vote on who we think the assassin is? Next Monday?
That may be a vote at some point, but I think we need a bit more time and info 🙂
Totally ok to throw theories around about it though :D. My favorite so far was Nycati and Prysen as an assassin couple, trying to do Kosandion in by sheer boredom hehe.
That made me laugh out loud mostly because of death by boredom. Bore your target to a coma and then kill him.
Aww, I thought the dancing healing fish was genuinely touching! Beautiful in every way. Switching to team Vampire though. Snarky knights all the way!
👍
+1
Wow. I picked Oond and his jazz fins for his deeply thoughtful comments. I assumed I would be the only one and there he is, surging to top of the waves.
I had picked wexyn in first vote. She seemed cute, calm and from Clan nuan. Have to love Cookie. But now she seems shallow, or deeply devious.
I also switched from Lady Wexyn (to Bestata in my case) but I don’t think that she is shallow. Devious, yes, but I am on the alert for House Andrews writing it so that every word she says is 100% true and 100% misleading. It’s too much fun watching her make Resven’s brain explode.
It seems to me that it was stated that the spouse’s role would be childrearing … and I would hope that child/ren in line for the dominion throne would be well educated and raised with significantly benevolent morals and ethics. In line with that, the spouse would need to be able to communicate and role model those mental capacities, morals, ethics, attitudes … now, I realize this is for fun, but, still, Kos must want his children to have the capacity to reign both complacently and competently…. we’re talking choice of both life-long companion and a teacher and role model for the children … so far, my vote is with Amphie for mental capacity and intellectual ability to deal with the demands of raising children capable of benevolently ruling 12 diverse planetary peoples … and Nycati as psionic who might be unable to make quick decisions, but certainly could protect both Kos and the kids. I don’t know whether to hope, or hope that it won’t, result in a 13-sided harem with fish, snow leopards, killer trees, killer birds, squiggly necked beings, psionics, elves, vampires and aught else as jealously quibbling parents, aunts and uncles!
Changed my vote from Ellenda to Bestata.
After reading all the speculation about who could be the assassin, I’m leaning to Ellenda (she’s pre mourning) and Lady Wexyn as anti assassin. 🤔
I voted for the fish, which was a change. Will almost certainly change my vote again, but the fish was just … Everything in that challenge.
I changed my mind from the kitty to the fish. 🙂
Me too!
Thank you! Can we also vote for the assassin?
Aye, yai, yai
The Inn should awaken tomorrow to discover that Nycati and Prysen have snuck away together to places unknown. They have withdrawn from the contest and wish to be left alone in order to delve into their inner selves, lost somewhere on a distant and boring level of the space/time continuum.
🤣🤣🤣
They left a forwarding address with Thek.
Yay Oond! That was my choice last time too. So glad their rank has improved in the polls!
Stayed loyal to Bestata. She has a good balance of warrior and sense. Not too cerebral but not too single-minded, either. I can see how the space fish having a collective-based focus would appeal to the social structure, but I fixated on the perception that Kosandion isn’t a fighter.
Given how House Meer were acting in regards to Nexus she is all the way out as far as I am concerned.
Changed my vote. It was Nycati but liked Ellenda and Amphie debate answers. Don’t trust Amphie so voted for Ellenda. Very surprised Oond has the most votes.
Team space fish.
I haven’t changed my mind! Lady Wezyn!!! I was between Amphie and Lady Wexyn, that debate convinced me!
I voted for Ellenda in the first round but went for the space fish. I mean, he has a beautiful personality and I also find it funny to think Kosandion’s spouse is a space fish. I freely admit that I am part of that sub population.
Oh, and aye!
I now think Ellende is the assassin. She is about duty (to her people), the mourning is what the uma wear when they are on a sacred kill etc.
I have not changed my vote from Lady W.
I don’t remember if I originally voted for Nycati or the kitty, but I definitely changed to Bestata. She reminds me of a cranky Karat. Absolutely hilarious!
I was Team Fish in the first vote. Glad to see everyone else got on board! 😂
Ellenda was my tentative choice from the first but after her debate she is firmly in first place. I am super impressed by Oond though. Amazing. I’m an introvert though so Ellenda’s quiet strength and gravity … ah heck it’s close.
Kinda disappointed by Kai and Priven, ugh. I guess that sort of metaphysical question needed to be hashed out but just ugh. Great diversion though. Huzzah our favorite writers!
This is way more interesting than those reality TV shows. I’ve only seen one or two episodes. It is impossible to escape them completely in American culture. The only ones I enjoy are the SNL parodies.
BTW I am loving the Graphic Audio versions of the Innkeeper series. I bought hard copy for my library. The mp3 discs are inexpensive and come in nice cases.
Yes, exactly! Ellenda’s integrity really impressed me. Objectively looking she probably lost her debate, but the way she did it in…
I was Lady Wexon the first poll, but voted for Oond this time around. His views and compassion impressed.
I’m beginning to understand how some contestants get through the rounds of some voting comps – sometime you want to vote for the agent of chaos, just to see what happens 😂
Switched to Prysen because I’m curious about him, their debate was so mind numbingly boring, it had to be deliberate.
As someone else commented earlier in the threads, I wasn’t intrigued by the Fish until then, I was. An excellent showing for Team Jazz Fins!
Aye
I changed my vote from Lady Wexyn to Bestata. After the introductions and the first poll my husband and I had the exact opposite opinion, with him liking Bestata and me Lady Wexyn. This vote he flipped around so if we both voted we would have canceled out each other but since only my vote shows, Bestata gets my vote. When she threw her hands out in proof Unessa was a dunce, I nearly fell over laughing. Truly House Meer needs the galactic boost and I see Bestata as an excellent vampire. I could be wrong but I think she seems solid, honest and true. Time will tell.
On the other hand I have a complex opinion of Caldenia and her nephew but it is so different than what has been portrayed in all the Innkeeper books to date I will keep them to myself. I did explain my thoughts to my husband and he said it was brilliant. So his opinion made me incredibly happy.
When you’re ready, the BDH is here for all the Here Be Dragons theories, especially the brilliant ones 🙂
Where do I go for the crazy theories please? I propose that Caldenia genuinely cares for her nephew and killed his father because the father was an evil git or something and Lady Wexyn is clearly a very intelligent, play-acting spy/agent maybe trying to alter the outcome of the trials? It’s not a well developed theory – clearly I need BDH input!
I have also assumed Caldonia killed her brother to save..nephew, or her subjects, or the Dominion. While she has NO altruistic feelings she may have a desire to be the ultimate savior of her people and there will be a time when it becomes known and she is again adored by her people even if not welcome back.
Yes! Also, altruism is one thing – but she must have been part of their group-emotions… hence altruism and egoism might have been more similar for her?
I thought it was pretty obvious what happened between Dina telling the story about how she came home after her test to find a garden full of mourning Dominion citizens + her story about how important the selection of the consort is to the emotional health of the Dominion. Obviously Caldenia was the best placed and best equipped to kill the Dominion leader (who happened to be her brother) once the emotional tipping point arrived for the Dominions populace.
However Caldenia is a master assassin with Many contracts out on her life (remember the guy with the fancy house who felt so insulted?) So I don’t think she’s actually hiding out from her family. It’s just not safe for her to go home, plus awkward she killed her brother.
+1
This is my theory, too.
My first vote was for Lady Wexyn. This time I was charmed by the fish. I voted for Oond. Not sure if Oond has the genes the sovereign needs but their offspring should be compassionate, cooperative and awesome.
I thought I was being such a weirdo voting for the fish, but you all are with me on that 😀 Woo hoo! <3
I’m surprised so many people seem to think that Cyanade won her debate, like… she forfeited, she refused to continue the discussion that means she lost. (Right?!)
I voted for her in the first round and not only for the kitty thing, she seemed intelligent and dedicated, but here she proved that she is not flexible in her believes and perception of others, which isn’t a great character trate for a ruler….
I also have a (mostly) unrelated question. I just rereaded Clean Sweep and through that book, Dina is reading a novel, the biggest clue is: “I was sitting in the foyer, trying to read a novel about angels and women who fell in love with them. The novel was great, but I couldn’t sink into it.” Does anyone know what is she reading? Just curious…
I am immediately thinking of Angel’s Blood by Nalini Singh. I love this series!
Second this and – no one shoot me – find I have to be in the right mood to read Elena and Raphael’s story (the first book), not so much some of the later books
Wow😲, thank you all for your inputs! Thanks Mod R ❤
+1
Maybe the Sharon Shinn Angelica series…
Yeah, I thought Sharon Shinn too.
Ditto, and I really enjoyed this series
It could be the Guild Hunter Novels, but there are a couple other angel based series. Mod R might know which is being referenced?
I don’t know, but I will ask 🙂 . There are so many possibilities!
I changed my mind from the first polls. Because someone who want to ease the suffering, even from his “enemy” is a good choice.
Lady Wexyn for sure!!! I would have love to be a fly on the wall for her and Caldenia’s “conversation,” something is up and I want to know. Caledonia knows something is amiss and what’s is going to happen. Oond, even to debated well and is gracious to me is playing the game too. Needless to say House Andrews is keeping us on our toes and I love it 😻
I realize with test tubes, surrogates, DNA sequencing and editorial license, a great number of interesting beings could produce a viable offspring. Perhaps careful and selective blending of all the candidates DNA would bring both Galactic interest, peace and a new species for future adventures.
I almost voted for the fish, looking at the comments, I see he somehow resonated with us. I guess the fact that he is a fish stopped me, even though he looks absolutely beautiful. Wouldn’t it be cruel that he would be stuck out of the ocean to raise his child?
Good point, didn’t even consider child rearing considerations
I think it would be an adventure Kos would literally have to completely redo his palace to add in waterways in every room and making sure there’s a large oceanic room for private space plus having Oonds bubble seriously upgraded in technology would benefit that whole species/planet. Even if they are never more than dna linked through an heir. I think that kingdom could do with an aquatic palace and if so I want alllll the ART!!! Plus little mermaid is my fav and my kid just completed jr musical version at school. Sooo team Oond!!
Yes! They should get Helen as an interior designer with her love for water… <3
Awww, such a cute picture….Congrats on the show! This brings back fond memories of attending many shows and musicals while my Mini-Me performed in them! Enjoy this time…they grow up too fast 😁💕
I thought that too Oono would literally be a fish out of water on his new homeland. However, he would see it as part of the cooperative system he believes in. Doing something for great benefit to his world and to help ensure their safety I assume.
Whoever wins may be the only one of their species on the world – for a min of 20 years – all making a sacrifice
My take on the Prysen/Nycati debate is that it’s a sign of either seriously incorrect preparation or some sort of strategy to take one of them out of the running, even if the other also loses. Since any study of past selections/Dominion politics in general seems like it would show you that making the entire audience need coffee is not a winning strategy, I’m voting for mutually assured destruction…
What an intriguing thought. Yes, deliberately flaming out is possible.
Someone mentioned them being bad leaders because they were indecisive, but I don’t think either lost (maybe people’s attention). They were there to debate and proved they could intellectually cross swords. Master Thek was impressed. I think they are both beautiful, smart and probably really lethal. Although I’d rather they debated something like Star Trek vrs Star Wars.
I did change my mind from the 1st poll.
This is so much fun! Thank Mod R! I was torn between fish (who knew? But the arguments was excellent and so was dancing for the enemy?) and Team Frowns, I didn’t think the BDH would be with me on this but apparently they are. I went Team Frowns ‘look, I would save the baby, I don’t give a fig’ is a powerful argument, especially when in mourning.
I voted for Nycati of Gaheas on the basis that psionic ability to “melt a sapient mind” could be a useful ability for the heir plus he has brains and doesn’t lack conversation, heh,heh. On the other hand, we don’t know yet if he has ulterior motives.
But the one dear to my heart (like so many of BDH) is Oond of the Oomboles – who knows, he/she/they might bring healing to the Dominions’ people, could easily become beloved by all.
Of course, must keep an eye peeled for Lady Wexyn; who knows what shenanigans are in store.
My previous vote was Lady Wexyn, but now it’s Oond of the Oomboles.
Ellanda has also moved up for me to second place, over Lady Wexyn. I actually liked Amphie’s response, but something about her doesn’t move me, so she is low-is on my list, along with the rest. Also, I preferred Unessa over Bestata, if only for the comedic factor (just for my entertainment, definitely not for marrying Kosandion)
Thanks for the poll, love it!
I couldn’t vote for Cyanide this time around because I don’t agree with the concept of fate. Oond, on the other hand, impressed me with an eloquently expressed view of the world that I mostly agree with!
Bestata was probably my second-favorite for the debate, but I’m still iffy on her as a spouse.
For me the compassion shown by Oond, even in the face of mockery and contempt, was a major deciding factor for me. His idea of strength is what we need more of in our society and in our lives. His dance brought tears to my eyes for all that it signifies.
I am always going to vote for the Otrokar, because I’ve been a fan of their people since they first showed up at Gertrude Hunt.
And because Kosandion needs this sort of infusion of ferosity and protectiveness to meet the concerns of his people.
And hey, Kosandion even said “And the debate goes to the otrokar” !
Ellenda twice for me, I just love strong defiant female characters. Also the photo chosen for her projects elegant strength to me- am I a bird in a study attracted to color leg bands? Or is she really the best choice? Unsure.
aye
Team jazz fins FTW! Yeah, I voted for Nycati last time, Oond pulled ahead in the debate. In a close second is Ellenda. This is so fun!
Jazz Finns 4evah!
Aye !
And may I say I love the profile pictures !
I wonder if some of the losing candidate will get marriage proposals either from other candidates or from the variety of beings watching this debate across the galaxy.
Where is Officer Marias? I hope he is around, or at least gets to watch some of the video later. (Maybe someone will nicely warn him to fast-foward over the boring “what is here” part.) I think he would get a kick out of this.
Was also wondering about officer Marais I thought Dina was hiring him for this but we haven’t seen or heard what he’s been up to..?
Officer Marais was probably hired for outside security, in case somebody decides to arrive from the front. Exactly that occurred in SWEEP IN PEACE.
I can’t believe it, but I actually adore Oond and Cyanide over the more humanoid aliens.
My vote went from Cyanide to the Donkamin candidate on the basis of their debate.
I get the fish thing, I really do, but it’s so obvious and I’ve been hit around the ears with obvious all day already 🙈
Kosandian seems kind of bored with the proceedings – maybe he’s thinking of abdicating 🤷🏽♀️
The Oond seems beautifully compassionate – lulling all into a false sense of security before they strike as the assassin- just a thought😏
I voted for Oond. Especially his idea of how safety is achieved is beautiful and has many benefits for society as a whole as well as the individual. Also I am moved by his compassion even while he is being mocked.
So I think he did the best. Do I think he will win the competition? No. I think that a man as powerfull as Kosandion has always known which spouse he would prefer. I think he must have worked very hard, probably with his potential spouse to make sure they won and earned the good opinion of the public. I do not think that he wishes to wed a fish.
I really dislike Lady Wexyn, but I think she will end up the winner. She is very smart, calculating and cunning. She is trying to mask it with sex, playing dumb and playing up emotions. She has aligned herself with a very strong backer (the lees do not play to loose, especially not clan nuan). Also: would Caldenia really talk to somebody unimportant? Nope. Either she is the assassin or her and Kosandion have been in luuurrve the whole time and have planned this whole thing through. Hope she is the assassin though because maaaaan I do not like her.
Oh and I can‘t stop reading the last chapter. It was everything I never knew I needed. Fills my mind, my heart and still makes me break out into giggles „we all lost!“
Kosandion has been a ruler for some time and he must have known for many years that he would marry/father a child through a spousal selection process. He rules an emphatic collective, one that can be fragile and has to be carefully manipulated to stay stable. I don‘t think that such a man would leave anything to fate, leave alone the selection of a spouse. And isn‘t he the one who has the „resists fate“ in his name?
The Author Lords had me at ‘jazz fins!”
I love this! I voted for Prysen originally. Admired the idea of ‘dignified wisdom’ but changed to Ellenda. Love the strong defiance and her debate answer. Also, I think she is loyal to Kosandion.
After re-reading the description of the Kai, I had to change. Now I think he might be a good candidate for the assassin— or Nycati, because he is already hiding something.
I changed from Bestata to Amphie. Though Oond made my favourite speech, Amphie gave the most balanced answer to the assigned question.
By the way, if we were just grading honesty I would still think Bestata > Amphie.
Yes, I agree. 00000Amphie speaks like a carefully-prepared, experienced politician. She sounds eloquent but not genuine.
Tough decision. Today’s vote was based on not only what their answer was, but also how they handled themselves.
Wish I could do a ranking.
Question: If the Oond is chosen, will the off spring be a child of air or a child of water? And so how can both parents then raise her/him?
Yes, even though technologically they can probably manage it (living arrangements), and the genetic mixing is no problem for them, it doesn’t feel like it would be a good life for a child to be born (or hatched, or otherwise created) as a literal fish out of water.
I didn’t change my vote. A significant number of the Horde picked the pretty goldfish with the fiery fins. The candidate said peace was most important. I would have changed my vote if the important thing was understanding or comprehension of the partner.
I switched my vote to Oond because 1. Oond debated best – might have had the best opponent for the Oombole perspective. (I have to admit that I LOVED ‘I wasn’t told to bring one’.) 2. Kosandion presents as one who loves the water. He often watches it, as if in escape? Maybe he would love for his child to have the option of truly escaping to the peace offered by deep, far reaching bodies of water. Since the sislaf treat their genotype as a template, I can imagine a person who can function equally well underwater as on land would be an interesting option.
Oohhh I never considered the water thing with Kosandion. Hmmm I concur. Also, it would be a mer-person. Literally. A mermaid/man. But think of how awesome that would be??
Trying to figure out what this marriage may need yet, my favorites are Cyanide and the Oond Jazz Fins. (I have a sneaking fondness for our favorite vampire observer but she may not be interested in an alliance.)
Enjoying your aliens, as always!
I absolutely changed. I voted Otrokar before but after debate the fish wins! Who knew debates are worth watching!
Aye
I vote Amphie, I liked her answer
Lady Wexin is cold and false
“Cookie” is so missing that I completely forgot about it, that’s not good, it’s making a mess like that! on second thought…………. Caldenia is also missing🤔 Poor Dina! frames of these two is too much for anyone 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
“Oond” won everyone at this stage, moved me and won my vote!
When the Sovereign goes to talk to the candidates individually, will Dina be by his side at that time?????
Yes changed vote, love the fish
The fish is winning 😂😂😂
Bestata was my vote.
Evidently I’m consistent so far, I went back & checked & I voted for the murder trees dryad. Again! XD
I love how th meme fish are winning.
Aye!
And still #TeamJazzFins
Quote from Chapter 13:
“Can the rankings be manipulated?”
He nodded. “They are numbers produced by emotions. Both can be manipulated.
* * *
Imagined conversation:
“Could we get the BDH to vote for the fish and still stay in the story?”
“Challenge accepted.”
* * *
I cheerfully accepted the ploy, but it makes sense too. The Dominion’s strength is its unity.
Also, I really liked this picture of Amphie. It went well with her debate response and how she has presented herself so far.
😀
Yep, I had the same “imagined conversation” in mind after reading the chapter 🙂
Great writing, HA!
Last time I voted for Nycati because of the psionic abilities, but this time I voted for Oond, because Oond is as beautiful on the inside as they are on the outside. I like Oond‘s “it takes a village” kind of message and the compassion for others. Nycati is still high in my list. I hope their deliberateness demonstrates self-restraint, because a psionic must be a very dangerous being.
I think it is really interesting that Oond is winning and I don’t think he’s winning because the BDH thinks it would be funny for a fish to win. I think there is something that resonates in what he has to say because all around us IRL the social constructs that have kept us safe are breaking down. Clearly it meant something to a significant portion of the BDH to have the idea of mutually assured prosperity articulated when we are living in an era of mutually assured destruction. I hope Oond wins. And yes, I totally changed my vote this time!
I find this assessment almost uncomfortably on the nose. To believe in a leader who wants to keep us safe is almost a pipe dream these days. Also, Someone with strength of character who might have been funny initially very quickly isn’t once they have opportunities to show their mettle. Neville Longbottom. Luna Lovegood. Winston Churchill. Very glad Oond took the opportunity.
Hmmm. I find the most popular favorites…interesting…
I’m surprised.
I voted for Cyanide last round. After the debate, I changed my vote to Oond. If only more people were like the fish.
I’m a cat person. Once one has lived with a cat, one becomes a cat person.
I’m not a fan of the idea of Kosandion ending up married to a fish because it’s funny, but I absolutely agreed with Oond’s arguments in the debates. I would happily see him end up the spouse for reasons of character.
My second choice would probably be Ellenda, or either of the two philosophers.
Mod R?
Yes? 🙂
Just nice to know you’re here!
Love the summaries. Me Unessa, You man! Very funny!!!
😊
You’re never alone with the BDH hehe.
Changed from Cyanide to Ellenda. For me, it came down to that she would save the child. And I’m not a big believe in fate, which is why I didn’t vote for Cyanide this time. But I also liked Oond’s response, safety and the caring for others with the dance. I also thought Bestata of House Meer had an intelligent response that helped her learn about her competitor and eliminate her from all consideration (not that Unessa had much of a chance anyway).
I definitely changed my mind since the first vote (when I voted for Lady Wexyn.) Lady Wexyn is fun to watch and is definitely hiding something (a brain??) but Oond’s performance this week (poetic answer AND a fish dance!!) sent me right to Team Oond!!
I don’t think this has staying power (we’ll see) but Oond deserved at least some time in the spotlight. 😍💕💕[Good Golly, am I actually singing the praises of a FISH? I need to get out more!]
Do I get extra credit for picking oond in the first round too? Somehow I feel extra proud that she/he/it(????) is doing well in the polls
I have noticed that OG #TeamFish people are very welcoming of the newly converted, but also retain a bit of sassiness over being there first 😀
OG Team Fish welcomes all converts and willfully ships all other matches to pave the way for victory. Also what may have started as just a joke vote has turned into something more.
Was going to vote for the fish from the beginning and for the same reason as the young people. Making your ruler marry a fish is funny. And knocking your elites down a peg is necessary.
But now I vote for the fish because he (she?) is wise. And wisdom should be cherished and promoted. Especially in leaders
Well I voted for the dark horse in the first poll, but that wasn’t available so yes, I changed my vote. And as I’ve started to dislike Lady W, I surprised myself by voting for someone I wasn’t fond of previously. Friday can’t come soon enough. Can’t wait to find out what the next challenge is!
I voted for Lady Wexyn in the first poll because I thought there was something more there and that even the leader of an empire needs love, but Oond’s message really spoke to me in this debate. I still think that there is something else going on with Lady Wexyn, but I find the simplicity a tad heavy handed on her part at this point in the competition. A ruler’s consort must bring strength to the union. For the public as well as the private.
I also think it’s funny that so many of us probably dismissed the fish out of hand in the beginning, as humans we cannot comprehend such a thing. But also how brave of Oond? To be willing to leave behind their entire world. They would most likely be confined to their modular bubble, no?
Let’s Go Amphieeeee!
So close to 2nd place
I originally voted for Nycati in the first pill, but his debate was so boring and verbose. I liked Bestata’s debate style more – direct and to the point, with snarky intelligence.
Was prepared to be odd man out… and so many others voted for oond.
They sound so beautiful, too!
Mention of roses just makes me think of Team Metal Rose! *romantic sigh*
Ah well – only picking one was difficult, so I went with the fish. Second vote to the the cat – yes I’m specist. Third vote to Lady Wexyn who will I suspect win, unless she is a very dark horse and retires to allow her choice to win.
Since I only got obe vote it went to Oond for style as well as debate merit. Lady Wexyn who was my candidate in the first vote lost style points in the debate.
And I would have liked to also give votes to Bestata, Ellenda and Surkar for their debate style.
Also Aye for the bromance debate duo.
I change from Cyanide to Ood. I love the story of the coral. I still like Cyanide and Nycati.
This is really fun
Thank you
There are two candidates I feel are most worthy: Cyanide and Oond. I voted for Cyanide over Oond because I figured Cyanide would have had fewer votes, and I was right.
But also, who wouldn’t want a big kitty around? Awesome.
Yes, Team Fish way to go!!!!
I choose this time to vote for Nycati – as I value discussions without too many emotions and trying to agree on something even if it’s difficult. But he’s still a bit of a mystery. Last time I choose Lady W, but I think she was to simplistic in this challenge.
I voted other BDH last time but went Higgra this time. Had a hard time deciding between Higgra, team frowns, lady w, bestata. I like oond as well but the otrokar comment of “you lost idiot” was my favourite.
Helo…I couldn’t find where to vote for other…I think Kon is going to make a play for Dina…so I’m voting OTHER…kelly
I voted for Team Smiles for both; I think she’d make the best spouse overall. I do love the fish, and I almost voted for the vampires, but House Meer is still in the doghouse for their duplicitous behaviour during the Nexus negotiations…
I love the idea that Ellende is in mourning for the impending death of Kosandion (although I hope he doesn’t die!!); what a cool plot twist that would be.
Thank you so much for doing these votes, with the pictures – such a fun integration of the BDH with the story!
I previously voted for Prysen Ol of the Kai, but, while I find debate to be fascinating when it gets technical, there is a limit to how technical. I voted for Bestata of House Meer this time, but if I could vote for two then I’d also vote for Ellenda of Team Frowns. Both of these two performed remarkably well in my opinion. I did not vote for Oond of the Oomboles, but I love their stance and the fact that they tried to show empathy for their competitor’s losses.
Hello,
Because of work I had to put off stopping reading. Today I read parts 14/2 and 15 and voted. I’m loving it. And the little treasures like them singing … the coffee… Orata asking to finish the debate of what is “here”… I’m really loving it. Please continue the good work, as I am now on vacation and catching up on my reading. But what a good start to the holiday. Thanks!
Tchau!
Aye!
Also, I changed my vote of “my favorite” from Lady Wexyn to Donkamin. But I have to say, I define “my favorite” based on writing, not on story.
One of the most important and enjoyable features of HA writing for me is the mastery of character development. Almost every character is multi-faceted, with positive and negative sides, twists, quirks and surprises.
Last time I found Lady Wexyn the most intriguing. This time she got not that much focus and stayed in line of the previous development.
The development of Oond this time is very enjoyable, but not really surprising – it feels like a nod from HA to BDH. Yes, HA can take a funny challenge and create a great story out of it!
So this time I wanted to acknowledge how HA found a positive side in a Donkamin, because believing in being self-made and self-reliable is a positive feature for me. BTW, do Donkamins have names?
And now I am really curious, if HA will let Unessa “save the cat” at some point? And, if yes, how?!
They do not have names, that we know of- or souls. Both of those things just up the creep factor for me 🫣
Hehe, high live the diversity! And versatility of HA writing 🙂
I went with Oond because its important to insure the non-humanoid-shaped citizens can see themselves in their rulers, pairing the Oomboles soothing ability with Kosandion’s physical prowess would make them a fierce couple and their child will likely be able to influence their targets emotions to some degree which is a huge advantage in a ruler.
I was tempted to go with Nycati of the Gaheas but I feel like its a bigger advantage in this case to have a spouse that can reach an audience that Kosandion doesn’t on his own. While Nycati’s power would be an asset, he does not have enough advantages overall in my opinion.
Plus it would be funny to see Kosandion marry a fish.
Aye!
You guys make me so happy. I’ve been feeling a bit sorry for myself recently as I had to have my hip replaced ’cause I couldn’t walk and the. I was swiftly losing my sight.
Your books plus many blogs really helped me get thru the hip surgery and most recently 2 eye surgeries. Your wit, story telling, plots and venue fit me to a tee. Thanks for the delight and chance to join you in my flights of fancy.
DRAGONBOGLE (age 80) 💥
Wishing you a speedy recovery!
Heh Picked a fish to be onery. The fish did have a lovely outlook on life. I will choose to think the best of my fellow bdh. Looking forward to the next round of antics.
All for the Otrokar after his one well-timed snide comment!
For me, Oond won the debate, but that does not necessarily make him a good spouse. I don’t have a good enough read yet on Kosandion yet to know who would be his best complement.
But I’ve realized that I also do not know what the status or expectations are for the spouse beyond staying 20 years and raising/influencing the child. There is an assumption, but nothing stated, that the winner would also be a companion, influencer and/or advisor for Kosandion but why should we assume that? They might lead totally separate lives except for the child connection.
I think I have a similar assumption to you, based on this bit in Chapter 13:
“We’re here to choose the parent of an heir and the spouse of the Sovereign. This person will have an impact on our society for decades to come.”
https://www.ilona-andrews.com/2022/chapter-13/
Far from being the joke of the choices, the fish is now the front runner! BOOYAH!
The jazz fins of compassion FTW
I think we now need to add another House Andrews online blog joke for things we really like- JAZZ FINS!
Can we start a poll on who the assassin is? I think the fish is out, but the rest are open.
While I like Oond’s personality as shown in his answer, I think that for a ruler, “safety” is not always the appropriate or best response. Rulers have to make the hard choices that affect other people’s lives, and a major default for “safety” might not be the best training for the future ruler.
Am intrigued by lady Wexyn, and think that there is something deeper there. Her meeting with Caldonia has me curious.
If there was an option for Other, I still am hoping for Miralit.
OMG! The overall results are my actual, personal rankings and win/lose votes!
Forget polling, Orata should just hire me!
Also,
Lady Wexyn’s being sneaky! It’s possible she didn’t lie.
She could love Kosandion . . . but what kind of love?
He could be her favorite- favorite potential sex partner, favorite space empire ruler, favorite . . . assassination target!
Sure, sure, she may never love anyone else in the exact same manner as she loves Kosandion . . . she’ll love them differently.
I was really hoping this one would be a set of one on ones for each debate pairing. Pretty sure my top 3 are all the same from last vote, though they might have juggled themselves about a bit.
Aye – LOL
I changed my vote from the first challenge. This is too delicious. Ummmm….
I voted for Lady Wexyn.
I think Kosandian needs someplace to forget all the burdens of office and she is as close as he will get.
2nd choice would be the Oombole for the sheer beauty of spirit.
Hi Mod R could you ask a question for me?
I would love to know if the picture that was chosen for Ellenda was the basis / inspiration for her being in mourning in the most recent instalment or if you just happened to find the perfect picture for something already planned. I love the insight into the writing process.
The photo was so perfect the paint was worked in the text 😊
Difficult to vote. The fish had some excellent points and I approved of the ideas. In the end, I stayed with Amphie because if you understand love or strive for it, that goal alone can encompass safety, stability, community and family. Love with discipline and learning can result in some great kids and great people.
I do like the idea of a side story about the prince in disguise because I find a prince skulking about quite entertaining. His debate in particular was befitting of politics–boring, said essentially nothing, pontificated as though more important than anyone else and kept all cards hidden to the point of losing any chance of putting forth a positive impression. Politics will do that to you.
Enjoying the story immensely.
I would guess Dominion citizens would vote off Donkamin, Unessa and Ellenda after the debate round. What do folks think?
I stuck with my original vote of Team Fish.
Has anyone asked yet why Kosandion switched the lineup? Wasn’t Wexyn supposed to get Oond’s question?
No 🙂.
Kosandion switched the order of the one-on-one dates, which happen after the debate is over 🙂. Not of the debate pairs or questions.
“What’s the schedule of the dates after the debate?” Kosandion asked.
“Oond of the Oomboles, followed by Amphie,” Resven said.
“Has it been announced?”
Got it, thanks!
Team Fish He’s pretty and she dances and they are the only one I’d care to have a date with. (sorry you were not gender specific and I don’t wanna piss off the pretty fish)
Oond is a male 🙂
“Oond spread all of his fins ”
“He raised his fins”
“His translator flashed”
“his fishbowl”
“He is dancing for you” etc
Oond of the Oomboles was my second choice 😁
Pretty kitty!!
Aye! And, I voted Oond. If I were a sovereign, I’d be suspicious to begin with about a spouse wanting to work against me. Oomboles attitude seems least dangerous to sovereign interests. And there is no demand to consummate marriage, just swap chromosomes.
I can’t wait to see Kosandion’s date and discussion with Ellenda. He seems eager to ask her about why (well, for whom) she wears the gold paint. I wonder, is it more empathy or curiosity?
I feel like they have more potential to develop an emotional bond over the other candidates, although that may not be his priority in the selection process. Actually, Amphie from Team Smiles seems like she’s intended to be the dominion’s prepared/pre-selected favorite. But she’s… less interesting.
My vote this time is the same as last time – Oombole from team jazz fishies for the win!
Ellenda in second, Bestata third, and Prysen in fourth. I’m happy to read how so many agree.
I would have liked to have voted for Amphie in the lineup but something about her strikes me wrong. Maybe her gollygee ain’t I perfect aspect. I wouldn’t be surprised if she were the assassin.
On the other hand Lady Wexyn is hilarious. I wonder if a large part of her performance is self-aware satire.
I mean really, how much can you know about your spouse from The Bachelor (intergalactic or not)? And her performance mirrors this.
Agree with you on Amphie . The constant adoring eyes would hide an assassin evaluating a mark really well.
Aye 🙂
I’m still hoping that the conclusion will be those two, and Bestata and Surkar getting together. Triple wedding grand finale? 😉
I have multiple flat “No” votes, a number of “maybe” votes, but Oond so clearly won the first contest that it really was no contest.
Did anyone else play the “What Is Love”
song by Haddaway while reading the debates?
Ear Worm for some time, fersure
I looked a second time, after I read all the comments. I still voted for Lady Wexyn and I believe Oond is not the one for Kosandion. The fancy finned fish in this world are dangerous. The first that comes to mind are the venomous Lionfish, and the second is the male hating Siamese Fighting Fish (Beta).
I liked Oond’s answer at the same time I’m voting Oond as the assassin 🙂
So now that the first challenge is over three are eliminated yes? Especially since the order of the dates is already known more or less?
So bye bye to Killer trees, the Donkamins, and the murder birds.
I don’t think the BDH has the only vote. We were allowed to vote to give our opinion. One suspects that HA has a preferred candidate that cannot be voted off the island.
I vote Lady Wexyn. I see her response as cleverly calculated to get her to the next round while winning the popular vote. Its a case of sorta winning the battle but definitely winning the war. In which case I feel she won the debate too. She’s Cleverly playing the game successfully on multiple levels.
Never thought I’d be voting for a fish, but Oond is my choice after this round. I was team Ellenda before this. Very hard decision
Peeeeeooopleeeeeee!!!!! You are so mean! I love you!!!!
By the way my bet is Prysen Ol of the Kai and Nycati of the Gaheas will have their own affair.
Waiting for Friday!!!!
I would clear up something, It’s Pride’s month and House Andrews’s statement is a a fish is the best because of its wisdom, empathy, kindness,… but it’s a fish!!! House Andrews say: I don’t care! Oonds is great!
I’m so proud of my House.
I changed my vote from Cyanide to Amphie. Cyanide seemed like a companion for Konsandion that would stay by his side. But the refusal to accept debate with someone “soulless” didn’t bode well for the empire’s empathy.
I really wanted Oond, but trapping you spouse in a fishbowl for 27 years seems cruel. Amphie, if she isn’t an assassin, seems like an intelligent person that may have goals similar to Konsandion. As for Lady W, chaos doesn’t seem like an asset in a empathic society.
Bestata then Oond.
I wonder if Dina has told Kosandion, Chancellor Resven and Capital Prefect Miralitt about the secret prince yet?
How long before the Dominion’s votes come in?
I’m curious will we get to see more of the candidates before they are ruled out.
I’d love a good description of the murder birds too, are they big emus?
Oond, changed from Cyanide. I didn’t like Cyanide’s view that if you are considered soul-less, you are worth-less.
Oond’s empathy is a wonderful thing. And Kosandion could always build bigger fish tanks/swimming pools.
p.s. I now believe that Lady Wexan is NOT a nice person. And I still like her for assassin.
And reviewing Ellanda’s answer and knowing she is in mourning, I wonder if she sees her duty as being in this Contest even though the one she really loved is dead?
I’m liking her more too.
I am so fickle
Since we’re doing conspiracy theories… Clan Nuan is only the Second biggest contributor to the Temple of Desire. Possibly Lady Wexyn is supported by the (unidentified) First/ largest contributor, and NOT by Clan Nuan . Cookie’s smile may have a very different meaning
Mod R, are we supposed to vote for the candidate that we felt won the debate or that we feel would be the best spouse? For me, they aren’t the same.
Also, I voted Dark Horse last time, but since that’s not an option that’s what is making me think that it should be the debate winner.
Thank you for doing this! 😊
Your favourite for spouse 🙂
Thank you for the clarification! 😊
Nay
Lady Wexyn is the assassin imho
I think so too!!!
Still want the werewolf girl as a contender
I can hardly believe I voted for a fish. But he’s brave, intelligent, empathic and seems to have given the most thought to these ideas. I’m giving serious thought to Cyanide. But really a spouse? A companion for decades and instructor of the heir? Damn. I still like the fish. But, no, I think Lady Wexyn will counterbalance Resven nicely, and we all know how duplicitous these grand vizier types can be.
I wonder greatly if Oond could sway the zeitgeist of the Empire so they would never want to kill Konsandion nor feel uneasy enough to break their society’s rules of good behavior.
Oond is my new favorite. I don’t know how the Oomboles find safety, but Oond may be the best for finding balance and promoting it. And Jazz Fins-how can any humanoid be more elegant and beautiful?
I am sorry, I can’t say no to Jazz Fins
Is it too early to start the refresh refresh refresh dance?
it’s 1505 here in the UK so 10 there. Totally too early.
Let me just refresh the other tab with the overall blog on it…
Hope you and your computers go somewhere nice with minimal stress and wrangling.
I vote for Oond. We need unity and peace.
Mind over matter may not work if the matter is your bladder which has decided it needs to empty of other matter.
f5 f5 f5 f5
arraggh, think strong thoughts. MIND over matter.
Liked the Mary Poppins reference hehe
I think Gaston will win.
Lady wexyn is the assassin!!! Heehee
For the last round there should be a panel like talent shows have with Cookie as one of the drafted panelist that wins them over as a dark horse.
So amazing the number of people responding and voting.