Hi everyone, Mod R here.
Writing Man has seen your enthusiasm and is very eager to receive his One True Name. We’ve gathered your top suggestions, please vote in the poll below for your favorite.
What should this magnificent writer be called?
- Edgar Allan Prose (21%, 1,515 Votes)
- Bartholomew de Horde (18%, 1,253 Votes)
- Archibald Scribblesbottom the IIIrd (17%, 1,209 Votes)
- Edgar Bookman (11%, 760 Votes)
- Ichabod de Plume (9%, 652 Votes)
- Quilliam McQuill Wordsfarthing (6%, 422 Votes)
- Bartleby van Writerly (6%, 398 Votes)
- Oscar LePage (6%, 397 Votes)
- Struggle McDramaface, Esq (5%, 329 Votes)
- Arthur Arthurson (2%, 118 Votes)
Total Voters: 7,053
Loading ...
One vote per person- the voting button is at the bottom of the suggestions.
Katja says
Thank you for reading over 900 comments to compile the list. What a grwat selection
Sabrina says
+1
Ms. Kim says
+1
Maura says
+1
KarenM says
+1
Ms. Kim says
SORRY THERE WASN’T A NAME ending in Wilde. But these were good choices. I went with Ichabod because he does look like an Ichabod.
Sara T says
+1
Same here 🙂
Angie Elle says
I was hoping for Moe Zart.
Hanna says
Wouldn’t it be great to find the person from these stock photos so he could find out the name he’s been christened with? 🙂
E says
+1
Dawn says
So many GOOD ONES. I had to choose one of my late kitty’s names though (Bartleby von Writerly).
sarafina says
+1
Melissa Bible says
I had to go with the Horde! HA HA Ha. Thanks for all you do. Cheers!!!
Dee T says
I especially loved that his initials are BDH?
Kelly M says
“Unable to obtain lock for Poll ID #62” not sure what that means but figured I’d pass it along;-)
(maybe magic wave messing with tech again?)
Kelly M says
(also when I refreshed and tried again it worked, so… short magic wave, LOL)
Moderator R says
Glad it was sorted 🙂
Samantha says
Ha! I love this, So going to point a finger at magic waves for all my tech frustrations. Thank you.
Kat in NJ says
Past life in IT tells me this was probably two different people trying to update the poll at the exact same time (down to the thousands of a second.) Freak occurrence (and the reason it worked the second time.)
All of that is IT speak for “magic wave messing with tech.” 😂
Annamal says
It is truly wonderous how often “turn it off and on again” (or its iis sister “recycle the application pool”) turns out to solve a seemingly awful problem
Lila says
He has Archibald face and I can’t unsee it.
Kandra says
+1
Donna A says
+1
Jessie West says
I like Bartholomew de Horde… BDH! Major props to whoever suggested that.
AP says
That’s why I also picked it! 😄 BDH for the win I hope! 🤞
Sechat says
+1
nedibes says
Agreed! Plus, I’ve wanted someone I could nickname Bardo ever since I first heard/read it, and he totally looks like a Bard-o!
Michelle Wittsack says
Struggle McDramaface, lol
Lenore Villa says
Need to think on this.
All such good names.
Artemus says
Actually I like Edgar Allan Prose best, but wondered if you might get into so legal drama as a result.
Maybe the TM / Copyright folks in the horde can comment. I’m sure there’s got to be some “Esquires” included. Right?
Moderator R says
Who has copyrighted the name Allan Edgar Prose, Artemus? 🙂
Bill from NJ says
Given it is obvious satire it would be protected, not to mention they would have a hard time arguing it could be confused with the real guy or hurt his estate or copyright.
there was a wonderful parody of Sherlock Holmes called Schlock Homes , be in same light.
Moderator R says
Names cannot be protected by copyright. Characters can. Since this is a clear parody, none of it applies 🙂
I wasn’t sure what Artemus was referring to, if she had encountered the name with “Prose” anywhere.
Fun fact: Edgar Allan Poe’s copyright doesn’t exist. Since his works are pre-1923, they are in the public domain.
Faith says
I love the factoids we learn here.
Marilyn H says
I received this message when I tried to vote:
Unable to obtain lock for Poll ID #62
One vote per person- the voting button is at the bottom of the suggestions.
I had only tried to vote this one time. Any idea what went wrong??????
I tried to vote for the last name on the list. The one that ended in “the III). It brought the most joy. I grinned immediately upon reading it.
Moderator R says
Please try to refresh the page 🙂
Kat in NJ says
I responded”Freak occurrence” to Kelly M when she had this same issue. Let it be hereby known that I am hanging up my “Retired IT Person Who Still Butts In With Unsolicited Bad Advice Cause She Can’t Help Herself” title and quietly backing away. Good thing I’m retired, no?!! 😂🤣😂🤣😂
Marilyn H says
Tried again, and it took my vote. Glitch I guess.
Tink says
Man, that was tough. Too bad the poll can’t do ranked voting. I was waffling between three of them.
Bill from NJ says
I voted for Edgar Allen Prose. If I had submitted it would be like like ‘Useless Twilley’ , a play on Eustace Tilley, which might be a mystery to those younger than like 70 or not an English major. Eustace Tilley was/is the sort of the symbol of the New Yorker magazine, a fop in a top hat looking at a butterfly through a monacle. I thought it would be funny on two levels, one that the guy in the picture looks, well, falling apart and frazzled ( and thus useless), but also because unlike our beloved IA books, the New Yorker is kind of the height of pretensiousness and takes itself so seriously (admission: I liked a lot of their cartoons, and occasionally they had an interesting article or 2; haven’t looked at it in close to 30 years). I don’t think Luther would like the New Yorker ( cracked myself up thinking about the profile they would write about Roland and Kate)
Wendy Z says
Hmm, I don’t see the button to vote under the list (or anywhere)
Moderator R says
It’s there- greyed out until you hover ontop of it 🙂
Kat in NJ says
What a fun poll, Mod R! Thank you once again for all that you do. 🥰💕
Rhonda says
I was all set to vote for Edgar but……. he looks like an Ichabod.
Siobhan says
Doesn’t he? Plus, Poe is one of my favorites. He doesn’t deserve that.
NANCY H says
I was split between the top two, so either one is great
Maren says
it was between Edgar Allen Prose and Ichabod de Plume. both HILARIOUS!! but in the end I went with Ichabod cuz that name always makes me chuckle. it’s just funny sounding!
Wilbur says
No fair having two variations of the Edgar names… it splits the Edgar vote!
Annamal says
The Edgar bloc is mighty
(and also all of the names are good)
Angela says
I still think Writer is Enby, but what will be will be.
Colleen says
Some great options! The Horde is *almost* as creative as IA. Although I’m a bit surprised Writey McWriter Face didn’t make the top (maybe it got vetoed by IA).
Also was kinda hoping for ranked choice voting but imagine wordpress polling doesn’t support that.
Rachel says
It wouldn’t allow me to vote – when I opened the page from my email, it went straight to the vote results, showing I’d “selected” van Writerly, but that would not have been my choice.
Lara says
we’re pretty ridiculous 😂
Shey says
Wordsfarthing just went like word-farting in my head – and since I am the queen of the brain-fart and he looks a bit frazzled and the whole quill play in the first two names, it was definitely Quilliam McQuill Wordsfarthing for me. (And yes, I also adore low-brow childish humor, and anything that reminds me of fart makes me smile.)
Pam says
I also liked Edgar Allen Prose a lot, but I had to bow to the BDH reference in Bartholomew de Horde.
Julie says
He’s been Bartholomew in my head from Day 1. He looks like a Bartholomew, and maybe his friends affectionately call him “The Bard”. “de Horde” is the perfect last name.
Siobhan says
My first instinct was Edgar Allan Prose, but Poe doesn’t deserve that. Ichabod le Plume it is!
Di says
Sticking w Ichabod!
Jean says
The Writer Guy Name Poll!! Almost too hard to choose one!
Thanks ModR and House Andrews for a slice of the funny side of the writing world!
📚✒️📜
Elenariel says
Almost gone with Bartleby van Writerly but then there was Bartholomew de Horde: he’s one for us!
Stacey says
Archibald Scribblesbottom the IIIrd won out for me. I giggled at the IIIrd part.
Amy Ann says
Tip of the hat to you for digging through all those suggestions. That was an amazing response from the BHD.
SueB, NH says
*sigh!* I really liked Mortimer best. He reminds me of Mortimer Brewster as played by Cary Grant in the movie Arsenic & old lace. Oh, well! 🙂
Onehsancare says
This needs to be done using a STAR voting or Ranked Choice Voting. It might be that everyone has the same second choice, so it would clearly make the majority of the BDH happier to have Name #2 be the winner, rather than just having the single highest vote-getter, the first choice of maybe only 18% of the Horde, winning.
There are apps to make that process easy—and it’s a low-risk way to see that there are alternative ways to look at voting.
Can we? Can we, please?
Jenna in Genoa says
Okay, I’m here to defend my choice…
Bartholomew de Horde.
Because he/she can always have nicknames:
1.) Barty D’Horde
2.) Hollow Horde
3.) Mew D’Horde
4.) The Horde of Bartholomew (think shiny, stabbing device… and lots of chainmail…)
5.) The Horde <- with a surname like De Horde, why wouldn’t you be known simply as “The Horde”?
6.) BART Horde <- If you live in the California Bay area, you should be laughing… 😆
7.) BD Horde <- let it come to you…
8.) Thol D’Horde
9.) Barry Horde (parents can sometimes be so unwittingly cruel about their kid’s names, don’t you think?)
And finally…
10.) BDH <— the acronym. Mod R knows this… she uses it all the time!
Laura says
Lots of good choices!
Spence says
He’ll always be McDramaface to me.
Honestly I’m just so stoked my recommendations made the list.
jewelwing says
Edgar Allan Prose is cute, but a little too obvious for me. Though I loved McDramaface, Struggle just didn’t strike me as a given name. Bartleby de Horde, for all the reasons outlined in comments above.
Courtenay says
I am curious where all the pictures of the same person come from.
Moderator R says
They are stock images that ilona buys for use on the blog. On stock image sites (Adobe Stock for example) you usually get to see if there is a series of images for the one you pick 🙂.
Pam miles says
Please vote for Archibald Scribblesbottom, that’s my grandfather’s name. He also helped construct the Ambassador Bridge, connecting Detroit MI to Windsor Ontario, a great achievement for any writer.
Angela says
it’s truly amazing that every time I check back that EAP is in the lead 23% to 18%, even though the number of votes keeps rising.
Cinders says
#2, for sure.
Samantha says
Poor Archibald, Edgar, Oscar, Ichabod, Quilliam, Bartleby, Arthur, Bartholomew, Struggle Thousands of us so torn on his name can only end in an extremely long one. Good thing he’s bookish.
Rowan says
Sad I missed this but I would’ve picked the name selected! Great job BDH!
Karla says
Archibald Scribblesbottom the IIIrd is my choice